Commission approves 1198 Valencia condo project after hours of public comment and conditions on parking, retail and unit mix
Loading...
Summary
After public opposition over height, shadows, contamination and affordability, the Planning Commission approved a five‑story mixed‑use condo project at 1198 Valencia Street with conditions (five discrete retail storefronts, reduced accessory parking roughly to 0.6 ratio, dedicated BMR parking, two car‑share spaces, and two additional three‑bedroom units).
The commission voted unanimously (6–0) to approve a conditional use authorization for a proposed project at 1198 Valencia Street that replaces a vacant former gas station with a five‑story, ~73,800‑square‑foot, mixed‑use building containing 49 dwelling units and ground‑floor retail. Department staff found the project consistent with the Eastern Neighborhoods area plan and recommended approval with conditions.
The proposal sparked broad neighborhood comment. Opponents raised concerns about scale and shadowing for adjacent retailers and residences, the site’s contamination history as a former Chevron gas station and adequacy of cleanup, the small number of on‑site below‑market ownership units (six), and the potential for market‑rate condos to increase displacement. Supporters including the Housing Action Coalition, neighborhood supporters and some adjacent property owners said the project replaces eight years of a fenced, vacant lot with family‑oriented housing and small retail that would activate the street.
The sponsor and planning staff said the Department of Public Health had approved the remedial cleanup plan and that the project will excavate the site for the underground parking, removing contaminated soils consistent with state and local standards. Commissioners pressed for additional design detail, stronger retail subdivision and a lower parking ratio. The final, amended approval included these key conditions: five separate retail storefronts at ground level; a reduced accessory parking arrangement (about 29–30 independently accessible spaces) with five dedicated below‑market‑rate (BMR) parking spaces; two on‑site car‑share spaces; and two additional three‑bedroom units (bringing the total three‑bed count to four) while maintaining the total unit cap approved by the commission.
The commission also asked the sponsor to consider the city’s upcoming density bonus rules in project sequencing and to provide improved bicycle parking design (staff noted double‑stack racks may be problematic). With the added conditions in place, the commission approved the project 6–0.
Next steps: staff will finalize conditions consistent with the commission direction and the sponsor will proceed with building‑permit level remediation sign‑offs and DPW/street‑use permits.
