Get Full Government Meeting Transcripts, Videos, & Alerts Forever!
Get email alerts on the Land Use Policy topic
No spam. Unsubscribe anytime.
Planning Commission continues Hayes Valley formula‑retail definitional change after wide public debate
Summary
After hours of testimony from neighborhood merchants, residents and businesses, the Planning Commission voted to continue Supervisor Breed's Hayes Valley ordinance (definitional changes to formula retail) pending broader study; commissioners split 4–3 on a procedural continuance.
The Planning Commission took up proposed planning‑code amendments introduced by Supervisor London Breed to expand the definition of formula retail in the Hayes Valley NCT district on Aug. 1. The ordinance would (1) count establishments with 11 or more locations worldwide, not just in the U.S., and (2) treat subsidiaries/affiliates as formula retail where 50% or more ownership is by a formula retail company.
Supervisor Breed’s legislative aide, Connor Johnson, framed the amendments as a local fairness and implementation measure: he said global brands had begun to circumvent the existing U.S.‑centric definition and Hayes Valley merchants wanted the code to apply evenly to international retailers and to affiliates. “Whether you like Hayes Valley’s formula retail ban or not, shouldn’t it apply fairly to all formula retailers?” he asked.
Planning staff recommended pausing action pending a citywide economic study of formula retail the department expects to publish in the fall; staff expressed particular concern about using ownership structure (percent ownership) as a land‑use determination without clear, implementable procedures. The Chamber of Commerce, retail trade groups and several commercial real‑estate speakers urged the Commission to wait for the department’s study; local merchants and neighborhood groups urged immediate changes to prevent displacement.
Outcome and significance: After lengthy debate about fairness, enforceability and precedent, the Commission voted on a motion to continue the Hayes Valley ordinance indefinitely (effectively until the department’s study and related Board action). The procedural motion to continue passed 4–3. Several commissioners said they support aligning the citywide definition but want the department’s economic and implementation work to inform any final code change.
What to watch: The Planning Department’s citywide study of formula retail, scheduled for release in the fall, and parallel Board of Supervisors legislation (introduced by other supervisors around the same time) will shape whether Hayes Valley receives a neighborhood‑specific definitional change or a citywide standard.
