Get Full Government Meeting Transcripts, Videos, & Alerts Forever!
Get email alerts on the Street Use topic
No spam. Unsubscribe anytime.
Board upholds Sons Edition sidewalk-cafe permit with limits on weekend hours and event days
Summary
After hours of testimony from neighbors and cultural-district advocates, the Board of Appeals granted the sidewalk-cafe permit for Sons Edition at 2990 Fourth Street with conditions: no outdoor seating during city-permitted block events and last seating capped on weekend nights.
The San Francisco Board of Appeals on March 21 upheld Public Works’ conditional approval of a permanent sidewalk-cafe permit for Sons Edition (permit 17TC0456) at 2990 Fourth Street but added clarifications limiting when the outdoor seating may be used.
Caliente Cuatro Latino Cultural District founder Eric Arguello urged commissioners to overturn or narrow the permit, arguing the full-service outdoor seating and later hours would conflict with the district’s emerging design guidelines and could set an undesirable precedent for gentrification on 20th/ Fourth Street. "By upholding this appeal, you will be giving Calle De Cuatro a chance to continue its work in protecting the vision and mission that was created through a community process," Arguello said in part of his testimony urging reduced hours and fewer seats.
Permit holders Nick and Anna (Sons Edition) told the board they had already reduced concessions made during the administrative review: "Our original permit was for 24. We've limited it now to 20 seats," Nick Cabruvius said, adding the business reduced divider size and agreed not to place tables during neighborhood festivals. Cabruvius said the additional seats are necessary to keep prices low and cover payroll for staff, noting the business has hired locally.
Public Works representative Brent Cohen summarized the review process, noting the office posted public notice, received dozens of objections and some letters of support, and conditioned the permit so the applicant must not occupy the permitted area during neighborhood festivals and similar city-permitted events. DPW staff recommended upholding the decision.
Commissioners debated possible hour limits to balance neighborhood quality-of-life concerns and the operator's economic needs. The board’s motion to grant the appeal and issue the permit included clarifying language that the permit is inoperative on days when the city issues a permit to close the block for events, and it limited the last seating cutoff on Friday and Saturday to 9:30 p.m.; DPW confirmed that the permit's occupancy of the right-of-way requires removal of tables and chairs by the end of the permit hours.
The motion passed with recorded ayes on the board's roll call. The board directed staff to clarify the event-related condition to reference city-permitted events on the block where the permit applies.
