Get Full Government Meeting Transcripts, Videos, & Alerts Forever!
Get email alerts on the Telecommunications Siting topic
No spam. Unsubscribe anytime.
Planning Commission approves T‑Mobile rooftop antennas at 1501 Lincoln Way with conditions after tenant opposition
Summary
Despite petitions and multiple tenant speakers raising health, notice and battery/garage concerns, the commission approved a conditional use permit for eight T‑Mobile panel antennas at 1501 Lincoln Way and required replacement of any removed bicycle parking; commissioners noted RF limits are federally set.
The San Francisco Planning Commission approved a conditional use authorization March 11 for a T‑Mobile wireless facility on the rooftop of 1501 Lincoln Way after residents raised health, notice and safety concerns during a lengthy public comment period.
Sharon Young of the Planning Department presented the staff recommendation to approve the project under planning code sections 209.6(c) and 303 and the 1996 wireless telecommunication siting guidelines. The proposal calls for eight flush‑mounted panel antennas on rooftop penthouses and an 80‑square‑foot equipment lease area in the building garage; this location was classified as a preferred colocation site because Sprint already maintains antennas at the address.
Rick Hirsch, the project attorney for T‑Mobile, said the company conducted outreach and a community meeting and that the installation would "greatly enhance the neighborhood" by improving voice and 3G data coverage. He added that the project team agreed to staff conditions of approval and planned to have a radio‑frequency professional available to answer technical questions.
Many tenants and neighbors testified in opposition. Speakers cited health worries about long‑term RF exposure, said they had not received adequate notice of earlier meetings, noted there are already three antennas on the roof and submitted a petition with roughly 65 signatures. Concern was also raised about backup batteries and other equipment being housed in the building garage and the potential loss of bicycle parking where equipment cabinets would be placed.
Commissioners emphasized the limits of local authority on RF health standards: permissible exposures are regulated by the Federal Communications Commission, and the Planning Commission may not deny a facility solely on health concerns if modeled RF fields are within federal thresholds. Commissioners and staff nevertheless discussed local policy aspects including disclosure to tenants, the lease relationship between building owners and carriers, and whether replacement bicycle parking should be required if equipment displaces spaces.
On a motion by Commissioner Mike Antonini the panel approved the conditional use authorization with the condition that any removed bicycle parking be replaced and with the other standard conditions recommended by staff. The commission also requested that the disclosure and tenant‑notification issue be relayed to the Board of Supervisors for consideration of possible policy changes. The motion passed unanimously.
