Get Full Government Meeting Transcripts, Videos, & Alerts Forever!
Get email alerts on the Urban Forestry topic
No spam. Unsubscribe anytime.
Board upholds DPW decision to remove declining Blackwood acacia on Fell Street
Summary
The Board of Appeals voted 4–0 to uphold the Department of Public Works’ removal permit for a declining Blackwood acacia at 1290 Fell Street after DPW presented photos and arborist findings of lean, root decay and sidewalk cracking.
The San Francisco Board of Appeals on Jan. 18 upheld a Department of Public Works order to remove a Blackwood acacia at 1290 Fell Street, voting 4–0 to deny the appellant’s appeal.
DPW Urban Forestry staff explained that the tree exhibited increased lean, girdling roots, decay at the root crown, and cracking in the adjacent sidewalk; photos submitted with the DPW brief showed canopy decline. The bureau said the species is not highly tolerant of root pruning and that after monitoring the tree staff concluded removal was the appropriate action. DPW also described replacement practices and recommended Brisbane box (Lophostemon confertus) as a replacement species while inviting neighbor input on species selection.
Board discussion covered life expectancy (DPW estimated about 60 years as a long life expectancy for this species in urban conditions), replacement species, outreach to concerned neighbors, and ensuring safe removal practices. Commissioners found the DPW presentation persuasive and voted unanimously to uphold the permit.
What happens next: DPW will remove the tree and proceed with replacement plantings per its standard maintenance program; neighbors may be consulted about the replacement species if they express preferences.
