Get Full Government Meeting Transcripts, Videos, & Alerts Forever!
Get email alerts on the Fillmore Formula Retail topic
No spam. Unsubscribe anytime.
Planning Commission signals disapproval of Ralph Lauren store on Fillmore after vigorous neighborhood opposition
Summary
After hours of testimony from neighbors and merchants who said a chain would harm Fillmore Street—s character, the Planning Commission voted an intent to disapprove a Ralph Lauren conditional-use request for 2040 Fillmore St.; commissioners asked staff to return with final language March 6.
The Planning Commission voted Feb. 14 to register formal intent to disapprove a conditional-use request by Ralph Lauren to open a retail store at 2040 Fillmore Street, following a lengthy public hearing in which neighborhood groups, merchants and residents urged the commission to keep Fillmore—s locally owned mix intact.
Planning staff had recommended approval with conditions, noting the existing space previously housed Smith & Hawken and would not expand the building envelope. Project representatives said they planned a context-sensitive facade and neighborhood outreach. Opponents told a different story: multiple speakers from the Pacific Heights Residents Association and the Fillmore Merchants Association argued the store would accelerate rent increases and erode the corridor—s specialized retail character.
"We oppose the issuance of the permit," said Thomas Reynolds, president of the Fillmore Merchants Association. "Ralph Lauren has kept that shop empty for a year right in the heart of Fillmore Street. That's something a big corporation can do that a one-of-a-kind shop would never do."
Commissioners debated whether the space would displace neighborhood-serving apparel shops, whether existing formula-retail stores on the block made the proposal a straightforward replacement, and whether outreach by the applicant had been sufficient. Several commissioners stressed that conditional-use review is intended to weigh local impacts; others said replacement of a formula retail use with another formula retail use still risks harming neighbors.
On a motion signaling the commission's intent to disapprove, the board voted 6-1 with Commissioner Antonini the lone dissent, and directed staff to return with final language on March 6.
Implementation note: the decision on Feb. 14 was an intent to disapprove; the project will return on March 6 for final language and any formal motion to disapprove the conditional use.
Key quote: "The voice of the neighborhood is very clear," Commissioner Catherine Moore said during the hearing. "The Fillmore Street is an extremely attractive and successful street, and I do not have any problem supporting that Ralph Lauren will not be in this neighborhood."
