Get Full Government Meeting Transcripts, Videos, & Alerts Forever!
Get email alerts on the Fire Fleet topic
No spam. Unsubscribe anytime.
Fire chief warns cuts to ladder truck, command vehicles would weaken response and mutual aid
Summary
San Francisco Fire Chief Janine Nicholson told the Budget committee that cutting an aerial ladder truck and command vehicle purchases would hinder the department's ability to respond to large fires and mutual-aid requests; the BLA recommended the reductions based on multi-year funding already in place and competing budget priorities.
San Francisco's fire chief urged supervisors on Aug. 20 not to approve analyst-proposed cuts to planned apparatus purchases, saying the department's fleet is aging and that cutting another aerial ladder or command vehicles would weaken city and regional emergency response.
"Many of our vehicles are literally being held together with Bondo and duct tape," Chief Janine Nicholson said, describing rigs more than 20 years old and high year-to-year repair costs; she warned that further delays in fleet replacement would increase risk to firefighters and residents and hamper mutual aid missions to neighboring counties.
The BLA recommended denying one additional ladder-truck purchase on the grounds that the city had funded six ladder trucks across prior budgets and the department is already receiving several new apparatuses. The committee and BLA noted that production and delivery of custom aerial trucks can be delayed by factory schedules and pandemic-related disruptions, and that several trucks ordered earlier in the mayor's multiyear plan are expected to arrive this calendar year.
Chief Nicholson also asked the committee to preserve funding for two command vehicles used to support the city's EMS 6/community paramedic expansion; department staff said those vehicles will be assigned to EMS 6 to support new street-crisis teams and that the operational program lacks sufficient vehicle capacity if the cuts stand.
The committee directed the BLA and the department to continue working together to find alternative offsets and to return with a refined proposal next week. Supervisors expressed gratitude for the department's mutual-aid work statewide amid ongoing wildfires and asked for further detail on which individual apparatus or vehicle lines are most critical.
What happens next: The Fire Department will meet with the BLA to explore alternative savings measures and return to the committee with a revised proposal and cost/operational impact analysis.
