Get Full Government Meeting Transcripts, Videos, & Alerts Forever!
Get email alerts on the Transit Advertising topic
No spam. Unsubscribe anytime.
Supervisors delay vote on SFMTA transit advertising contract after concerns over bus wraps and branding
Summary
The Budget & Finance Subcommittee paused a proposed SFMTA advertising contract that would guarantee at least $28.5 million over five years after supervisors and public speakers raised concerns about bus wraps covering Muni branding; staff said wraps would be limited and generate revenue for Muni operations.
The San Francisco Board of Supervisors Budget & Finance Subcommittee on Wednesday took up a proposed transit advertising contract the San Francisco Municipal Transportation Agency negotiated to replace an expiring agreement and to provide a minimum guarantee of $28,500,000 over the initial five‑year term. SFMTA staff said the contract was competitively procured and includes a minimum annual guarantee and a revenue‑share structure.
Budget analyst Mr. Rose told the committee the first‑year minimum guarantee is $5,400,000 and the total minimum payable over the initial five years is $28,500,000, with annual CPI adjustments and additional administrative and marketing fees. “Based on the competitive process, we recommend that you approve this legislation,” he said.
Several supervisors and members of the public raised objections focused on bus wraps — large advertisements that can cover significant portions of vehicle exteriors. Supervisor Obelos objected to wraps that could obscure Muni branding, citing the city’s recent repeal of Sunday metering and questioning whether the administration had exhausted other revenue options. “I am not ready to support this contract with the ads the way they are,” the supervisor said.
SFMTA staff responded that wrap placements would be limited and that visibility from inside the buses has improved with newer wrap materials. Gail Stein said the existing policy allows up to 15 wrapped vehicles and the new contract would allow up to 30 at the agency’s discretion, while noting that wrapped vehicles historically are a small share of the fleet (currently seven wrapped vehicles in a fleet of over 1,000, or less than 3%). She also said removing the 15‑vehicle minimum would reduce the minimum annual guarantee by $325,000.
Deputy City Attorney John Gibner told the committee the Board has an up‑or‑down vote on the contract. After a brief public comment urging preservation of the Muni logo, Supervisor Avalos moved to continue the item to the call of the chair for further negotiation with SFMTA and the contractor. The motion to continue was taken without objection, and committee members committed to resolve supervision concerns quickly so the expiring contract does not lapse.
The committee did not take a final vote on the contract. The SFMTA said it is willing to discuss wrap limits and other options with supervisors and the contractor before the Board considers approval.
