Get Full Government Meeting Transcripts, Videos, & Alerts Forever!
Get email alerts on the Retirement Fund topic
No spam. Unsubscribe anytime.
Rules Committee forwards mayoral retirement board nominee after extended hearing on divestment and conflicts
Summary
The committee forwarded the mayor’s appointee Scott Helfon to the full Board with a positive recommendation after a lengthy candidate presentation, supervisor questions about potential conflicts with Aon Hewitt, and a large public comment period urging stronger divestment from fossil fuels and strict conflict‑of‑interest standards.
The Rules Committee voted March 18 to forward the mayor's appointment of Scott Helfon to the San Francisco Retirement Board to the full Board with a positive recommendation after an extended hearing and considerable public comment.
Helfon, introduced by the clerk as the mayor’s nominee, described his background in municipal health services and his work on environmental, social and governance (ESG) investing. When asked about past concerns he said prompted his resignation from a prior health services role, Helfon said he had "done my due diligence" and did not currently see a conflict with Aon Hewitt or other city business.
Supervisor Ahsha Safai stressed the retirement fund's primary responsibility to beneficiaries and asked Helfon for concrete steps on divestment from fossil fuels; Helfon said he supported divestment and cited progress on ESG strategies. Safai and other supervisors noted the fund has grown substantially in recent years; committee discussion recorded fund growth "from $19,000,000,000 to $24,000,000,000" and a 90 percent funded level.
Public comment was strongly focused on fossil‑fuel divestment and fiduciary concerns. Jeremy Pollack of Fossil Free San Francisco highlighted sector performance charts and told the committee the energy sector was "down 24%" over a five‑year period, urging oversight of the retirement board. Jed Holtzman of 350 Bay Area said community advocates have seen board motions approved that staff later did not implement. Union and retiree speakers urged appointments free of conflicts and mindful of fiduciary duties.
After public comment, Supervisor Walton moved to forward the appointment as a committee report, noting receipt of a revised memo correcting the term to a five‑year term expiring in February per the code; the motion passed without objection. The full Board will review the appointment on its upcoming agenda.
