Get Full Government Meeting Transcripts, Videos, & Alerts Forever!
Get email alerts on the Hate Crimes topic
No spam. Unsubscribe anytime.
Utah House approves bill to collect statewide hate‑crime statistics; effort to add sexual orientation fails
Summary
The Utah House passed HB 111, requiring law enforcement to report hate‑crime data to the Department of Public Safety. An amendment to explicitly add sexual orientation to reporting categories failed on the floor; sponsors said the bill aims to standardize data collection, not to change speech or civil‑rights law.
The Utah House of Representatives voted to approve House Bill 111, a measure to require uniform reporting of hate‑crime statistics to the Department of Public Safety, and sent the bill to the Senate.
Sponsor Representative Picconelli told colleagues the Department of Public Safety and law‑enforcement groups support the bill because it creates a single, standardized system for collecting data on crimes motivated by prejudice. "This bill is about putting together facts and figures on different crimes," Picconelli said, arguing that better data will let officials "find out the nature of the problem, the degree of the problem, and take action to correct it." Representatives emphasized the measure is statistical in scope and does not criminalize protected speech.
On the floor, Representative Ward offered an amendment to insert "sexual orientation" among the categories to be reported. Supporters, including Representative Rose and Representative Atkinson, argued the change would acknowledge crimes they said disproportionately affect gay and lesbian people. Opponents, led by Representative Nelson, said including the phrase would be legally and politically problematic under current Utah law and raised constitutional concerns. A point of order was sustained when a member accused another of impugning motives during debate.
The amendment to add sexual orientation failed in a recorded vote. After closing remarks and clarifications from sponsors about the bill's limited, statistics‑collection role, the House approved HB 111 by a roll‑call tally of 60 affirmative votes and 9 negatives. The clerk recorded that the bill will be forwarded to the Senate for further consideration.
What happens next: HB 111 moves to the Senate for its consideration. The measure, as approved by the House, requires law‑enforcement agencies to submit standardized incident and category data to the Department of Public Safety while protecting victim identities in published reports.
