Get Full Government Meeting Transcripts, Videos, & Alerts Forever!
Get email alerts on the Religious Liberty topic
No spam. Unsubscribe anytime.
Utah House rejects SJR 8 after heated debate over timetable and minority protections
Summary
The Utah House voted down Senate Joint Resolution 8, a proposed constitutional amendment to broaden religious-liberty protections, after lengthy floor debate about whether to advance a concrete amendment now or send it back for more hearings. Final tally: 45-28 against.
The Utah House of Representatives on the March 1993 floor rejected Senate Joint Resolution 8 (SJR 8), a proposed amendment to the state constitution that would broaden protections for religious exercise and minority religions, after a daylong debate over process and potential effects.
Representative Valentine, who opened the debate, described the moment as "historic," saying SJR 8 "does 5 things" including accommodating free exercise and protecting minority religions and that passage would start the ratification process. Supporters argued the text provided a concrete proposal for voters to consider and would remove restrictive language that some judges had read to limit public religious expression.
Opponents pressed for more study and broader public input. Representative Buffmeier warned the proposal "seeks to expand to the maximum degree permitted by the federal constitution" and said it "threatens the principle of separation of church and state." Several members asked that the resolution be returned to the religious liberties committee, the Constitutional Revision Commission and the judiciary interim committee for additional hearings rather than placed on the ballot immediately.
Representative Goodfellow offered a substitute amendment intended to slow the process and reinstate the religious liberties committee for additional public hearings; he told colleagues the substitute "would give them the opportunity to continue to have public hearings, to have input," but the motion to substitute failed on a division vote. Representative Ballantine, in a closing summation, urged members to let voters "decide" on a concrete proposal and emphasized provisions in SJR 8 that "broadens the rights of minority religions."
After a call of the House and final roll, the resolution failed 45 to 28 and will not advance to the ratification phase. The House record shows the vote and the decision ends the measure’s immediate path to the public ballot; supporters may pursue alternative legislative or committee routes but no further action on SJR 8 was taken in this session before recess.
The debate repeatedly balanced two procedural positions: those who argued that a concrete amendment should be presented to the public now and those who urged slower, more inclusive study to protect minority rights and avoid unintended legal consequences. The House also addressed several other bills during the session, including funding and taxation measures, housing finance amendments and wildlife-management statutes.
