Citizen Portal
Sign In

Get Full Government Meeting Transcripts, Videos, & Alerts Forever!

Get email alerts on the State Local Relations topic

No spam. Unsubscribe anytime.

House adopts resolution on unfunded mandates after extended debate over state-local responsibilities

Utah House of Representatives · February 10, 1995
AI-Generated Content: All content on this page was generated by AI to highlight key points from the meeting. For complete details and context, we recommend watching the full video. so we can fix them.

Summary

The House adopted HJR 15, an amended nonbinding resolution protesting unfunded or unnecessary mandates on cities and counties; debate featured competing views about constitutional roles, funding and administrative burdens before passage 43–24.

Representative Oskarsson opened debate on HJR 15, a resolution protesting unfunded state mandates that local governments must enforce. He said municipalities had identified dozens of mandates that impose financial burdens and asked the House to adopt a statement urging caution when drafting laws that affect local budgets and operations.

Opponents argued the resolution oversimplified the relationship between state and local governments. Representative Howard warned that the state has different responsibilities and constitutional limits than the federal government, and that the resolution as drafted was "too broad." Representative Hayman, speaking from mayoral experience, said the resolution "can do no good" if it is used to avoid necessary state-level regulation.

Supporters countered that the resolution, as amended in committee, explicitly objects only to "unfunded, unnecessary, or avoidable mandates," and urged the House to adopt a posture of dialogue with local governments. Representative Mortimer urged caution about equating state action with federal overreach and emphasized the need to address the substance of particular mandates.

The House voted on the previous question and then passed HJR 15 as amended, 43 yes to 24 no. The resolution is nonbinding and will be forwarded to the Senate for their consideration. Members emphasized that the resolution aims to encourage clearer communication, funding where appropriate, and appeals procedures between state agencies and local governments.