Get Full Government Meeting Transcripts, Videos, & Alerts Forever!
Get email alerts on the Education Policy topic
No spam. Unsubscribe anytime.
House approves resolution asking courts to clarify moment-of-silence rules
Summary
The Utah House passed HJR 6 calling for consideration of a moment-of-silence resolution; supporters said it provides optional, nonsectarian time for reflection in schools while opponents warned it could be a pathway to introducing prayer into classrooms. The resolution passed 65-5 and was sent to the Senate.
Representative Matt Johnson presented HJR 6, a resolution asking that a moment of silence be made available in schools as an optional, nondiscriminatory measure. Johnson said the resolution is intentionally soft and not mandatory, allowing local districts, schools and families discretion over whether to adopt a moment of silence.
Supporters argued a short period of quiet can provide students time to reflect or prepare for class and is consistent with tolerance for different beliefs. Representative Johnson read a legal opinion excerpt stressing the resolution should avoid sectarian prayers and noted staff review found no constitutional or statutory conflicts in the resolution's current wording.
Opponents, including Representative Carlson, cautioned that a moment of silence could be used as a substitute for prayer and said there is no need to amend the Constitution to permit an optional moment of silence in schools. The exchange included references to past debates over prayer and to differing legal interpretations; the sponsor responded that the resolution simply clarifies that schools may adopt a moment of silence if they wish.
The House voted and the Clerk announced HJR 6 passed with 65 yes votes and 5 no votes. The resolution was then referred to the Senate for consideration.
