Get Full Government Meeting Transcripts, Videos, & Alerts Forever!
Get email alerts on the Education Policy topic
No spam. Unsubscribe anytime.
House approves first substitute to give teachers more say in core curriculum, rejects amendment to shift approval power
Summary
The House passed the first substitute to Senate Bill 99, which increases teacher and parent involvement in setting core curriculum and gives districts more flexibility in instructional materials. A proposed amendment to change 'recommended' lists to 'approved' was defeated after lengthy floor debate.
On Feb. 27 the Utah House passed the first substitute to Senate Bill 99, a measure designed to give teachers and parents more input on core curriculum and allow school districts greater flexibility in selecting instructional materials and teaching methods.
Representative Derry, floor sponsor for the substitute, said the legislation aligns the core curriculum with assessments and returns discretion to teachers and principals to choose materials they deem most effective. The bill also preserves an approval process while allowing districts to select from state-recommended instructional materials.
Rep. Cheryl Allen offered an amendment to make instructional selections "subject to local school board policy," and Representative Sidaway later proposed substituting the word "approved" for "recommended" in multiple spots. Proponents of the amendments argued they preserve local accountability and bulk-purchasing savings; opponents said the changes would undercut teacher-level flexibility and the objectives of the substitute by reintroducing statewide mandates.
Representative Sidaway argued there is a practical difference between 'recommended' and 'approved' language because approval carries more rigorous review and would limit some local adoptions, while Representative Dilrie and others said the state approval process protects students and helps secure bulk-purchase discounts.
After extended debate and a division vote on the Sidaway amendment (27 yes, 40 no), the amendment failed. The House then voted to pass the first substitute to SB99 with a final tally of 56 yes and 14 no; the bill will be returned to the Senate for signature.
Next steps: Passed substitute returns to the Senate; districts and the state board will coordinate implementation under the enacted language.
