Get Full Government Meeting Transcripts, Videos, & Alerts Forever!
Get email alerts on the Consumer Protection topic
No spam. Unsubscribe anytime.
House circles vehicle‑report disclosure bill after debate on consumer harm and data access
Summary
Representative Curtis presented Senate Bill 151 to allow bulk electronic disclosure of vehicle accident reports (make, model, year, accident date). Representative White warned that routine publication could harm owners by reducing resale value. The House voted to circle the bill for further amendment and review.
Representative Curtis introduced Senate Bill 151 on March 6, 2002, a bill amending a provision related to vehicle accident reports to allow the department to disclose accident information in a bulk electronic format to requesting parties.
Curtis explained the amendment would permit release of structured data (vehicle make, model, year and accident dates) to help consumers researching vehicle history. Representative White raised consumer‑protection concerns, saying broad access to accident‑history data could impose a "diminution of value" on vehicles that have been repaired after accidents, and warned that exposing that information broadly could hurt individual owners. White said prior proposals had attempted to protect accident reports and that industry actors such as CARFAX had engaged lawmakers about legislation.
After discussion, the House voted to circle Senate Bill 151 to allow time for amendments and further consideration. Sponsors and critics agreed more work was needed to balance consumer information and potential harm to owners and to craft protections if data disclosure is allowed in bulk electronic form.
The bill was circled for amendment and further floor action.
