Get Full Government Meeting Transcripts, Videos, & Alerts Forever!
Get email alerts on the Adoption Records topic
No spam. Unsubscribe anytime.
Utah House rejects bill allowing adoptees to petition courts for confidential intermediaries
Summary
After extended floor debate and two adopted amendments, the Utah House narrowly rejected HB 289 — which would have allowed 30-year-old adoptees to petition for court-appointed confidential intermediaries to contact birth parents — by a 35–36 margin on Feb. 19.
The Utah House heard extensive floor debate on House Bill 289 on Feb. 19 before ultimately filing the measure after a narrow defeat.
Sponsor presentation and two floor amendments: Representative (sponsor of HB 289) described the bill as a compromise to allow a 30‑year‑old adoptee to petition a court for an intermediary to locate birth parents, with court-appointed intermediaries making discreet contact and returning to the court if parents are located or deceased. Amendment No. 1 removed fiscal notes so petitioning adoptees would bear the court filing costs (the sponsor noted an approximate $400 filing fee). Amendment No. 2 added a statutory definition of "confidential intermediary." Both amendments were adopted on the floor.
Supporters emphasized adoptees’ interest in identity and medical history. Representative Hutchings said the bill would help adoptees “gain a sense of who they are” and called it a reasonable compromise; Representative Hughes described it as carefully balanced to protect birth parents while allowing adoptees a path.
Opponents argued that the bill risked uninvited intrusions on birth parents who may have moved on with their lives. Representative Fisher warned that a birth parent could face an unexpected and devastating contact decades later; Representative McKiss urged caution given deeply personal circumstances and urged thoughtful consideration.
Sponsor and supporters said the bill preserved parental control over disclosure: if a birth parent declined contact after intermediary inquiry, "that's the end of the story," the sponsor said. The sponsor also noted criminal penalties for intermediaries who breach confidentiality (a Class A misdemeanor in the bill text).
Final tally and outcome: After debate and a successful previous-question motion, the House voted on HB 289 as amended. The bill failed by one vote: 35 yes, 36 no, with 4 absent. The Speaker announced the bill "fails and shall be filed."
