Get Full Government Meeting Transcripts, Videos, & Alerts Forever!
Get email alerts on the Transportation Safety topic
No spam. Unsubscribe anytime.
House amends and passes bill to increase fines for unsecured highway loads after debate
Summary
The Utah House amended and passed first substitute Senate Bill 44 to raise penalties for unsecured and dangerous highway loads, following debate over enforcement and a close floor amendment vote; the bill passed the House 67–1 (7 absent) and will return to the Senate.
The Utah House on Feb. 14 amended and approved first substitute Senate Bill 44, which raises penalties for unsecured loads and littering on state highways and exempts certain heavy construction debris.
Representative Allen, the bill sponsor, told members the measure responds to serious safety incidents and high cleanup costs. "UDOT spent $2,000,000 last year to remove debris," she said, and described a 2007 crash in Kaysville in which a steel scaffolding brace became airborne and seriously injured a driver. Allen moved Amendment No. 2 to reinstate an exemption for heavy or scrap metal that is unlikely to blow from a vehicle.
Floor debate focused on enforcement and the mechanics of reporting unsecured loads. Representative Harper moved to delete two sections that would have required rulemaking to allow public reporting of violations, arguing it could create a ‘‘he said, she said’’ enforcement problem. Harper said the reporting provision "sets us up for he said, she said" and worried it would clog courts. Supporters of leaving reporting authority in the bill, including Representative Ballon, said administrative rules could help identify sources of dangerous debris; Representative Ballon noted the origin of the Kaysville steel brace was "unknown" in the police report and argued rules could aid enforcement.
Other members cited officer and motorist safety. Representative Greenwood recounted near-misses as a trooper and urged support; Representative Oda described a firefighter killed in a rollover attributed to fallen ladder debris and said "we need to make it mean something." Representatives Darr and Hemingway questioned whether higher fines alone would curb littering and urged better-funded public-education campaigns.
The bill sets higher fines in the statutory text presented on the floor: for noncommercial unsecured loads a first offense would be raised to $100 and a second offense within three years to $250 (the sponsor said the current noncommercial fine is $40); for commercial loads the sponsor described first- and second-offense levels (sponsor remarks referenced $250 and $500 figures for first and second offenses). The legislation also directs increased UDOT education and publicity efforts.
A motion to amend (delete the reporting provisions) passed by division on a narrow 35–34 tally earlier in the debate; the House later voted on the bill as amended and recorded 67 yes, 1 no, 7 absent. The bill will be forwarded to the Senate for further consideration.
The House additionally waived summation at points during debate and clarified that Amendment No. 2 (the construction-debris exemption) would remain in the bill as adopted on the floor.
The House is expected to transmit the amended bill to the Senate for signature and further action.
