Get Full Government Meeting Transcripts, Videos, & Alerts Forever!
Get email alerts on the Education Policy topic
No spam. Unsubscribe anytime.
House rejects bill directing school districts to adopt parental-involvement policies after amendment debate
Summary
The House debated and then rejected third substitute SB 199, a bill directing local boards to develop policies promoting parental involvement and preventing preferential treatment for one parent group over another. Representative Powell’s amendment reframed the requirement toward promoting involvement for all parent groups; the amended bill failed on final passage, 30–43.
The Utah House considered and ultimately rejected a measure directing local school boards to adopt policies aimed at ensuring fair access for parent groups, voting down third substitute SB 199, 30–43, on March 12, 2009.
Representative Lockhart, the sponsor, said the third substitute emphasized local control while instructing districts to adopt policies preventing preferential treatment of one parent group. Representative Powell offered an amendment that reframed the requirement positively — that school boards "shall develop policies that promote involvement by all parent groups that wish to participate within the school district and its schools" — language supporters described as a "warm and fuzzy" alternative intended to avoid trapping administrators in legal uncertainty.
Floor debate was extensive. Proponents argued the change would ensure inclusive parental participation amid local disputes; opponents said the legislature should not intervene in what they described as local, personality-driven disputes and worried about burdening administrators with becoming referees among parent groups. Representative Moss warned the bill was unnecessary and could sow discord and administrative burdens. After amendments were adopted and further debate, the House rejected the third substitute on final passage (30 yes, 43 no) and referred the matter to staff for filing.
