Get Full Government Meeting Transcripts, Videos, & Alerts Forever!
Get email alerts on the Licensing Private Investigators topic
No spam. Unsubscribe anytime.
House passes SB177 raising private-investigator licensing experience threshold amid amendment fight
Summary
The Utah House passed Senate Bill 177 on March 10, 2011, raising initial private-investigator licensure requirements and adding insurance protections. An amendment to reduce the new 10,000-hour experience threshold to 4,000 hours and to change residency language failed after debate about industry negotiation and public protection.
The Utah House passed Senate Bill 177 on March 10, 2011, by a recorded vote of 40 yes and 27 no. The bill, sponsored in the House by Representative Grover, raises initial qualification requirements for private investigators, requires minimum liability insurance for agencies, allows certain college credits and POST standards to count toward licensing, and was presented as a negotiated, industry-led effort to improve quality and keep Utah jobs in-state.
Representative Grover, the House sponsor, framed the bill as "an attempt by the private investigators to regulate their own industry," saying the package had been worked on for months with the attorney general's office, Department of Public Safety, BCI, the Private Investigator Association and the Utah State Tax Commission. He said the negotiated language was meant to "raise the standards of PIs to ensure higher quality service" and to protect the public through insurance and minimum qualifications.
During floor debate Representative Cox moved to amend the bill to (1) insert the words "and The United States" after the phrase "of this state" (affecting residency language), and (2) replace the proposed 10,000-hour qualification with 4,000 hours. Cox argued the 10,000-hour or five-year apprenticeship requirement would be onerous and could lock out otherwise qualified entrants, saying, "What this is basically saying is somebody that wants to become a private investigator will need to have 10,000 hours or 5 years of apprenticeship, which I think would be really great for those that currently are licensed, but those that want to get in the profession, perhaps may not want to wait 5 years." Sponsor Grover and others countered that the threshold had been carefully negotiated with DPS and the PI Association and that the higher threshold was intended to ensure quality and prevent questionable claims of experience.
The motion to amend was put to a vote and failed. After additional discussion and affirmations of the negotiated nature of the bill, the House voted for final passage. The bill will be transmitted back to the Senate for further consideration.
What happens next: The House-recorded vote will be transmitted to the Senate and to enrolled bill processes. If enacted as amended through the Senate (or following any conference committee), the changes would alter Utah's licensing pathway and state-level minimum protections for private-investigator services.
Vote: SB177 — passed in the House, 40 yes, 27 no.
Ending: The House returned most concurrence items and continued through a lengthy floor calendar; SB177 was among the bills the chamber sent forward for further Senate consideration.
