Citizen Portal
Sign In

Get Full Government Meeting Transcripts, Videos, & Alerts Forever!

Get email alerts on the Constitutional Federalism Defense Act topic

No spam. Unsubscribe anytime.

House approves bill creating a legislative federalism commission; supporters cite state sovereignty

Utah House of Representatives · March 1, 2013
AI-Generated Content: All content on this page was generated by AI to highlight key points from the meeting. For complete details and context, we recommend watching the full video. so we can fix them.

Summary

The House passed Substitute House Bill 131 to establish a legislative federalism commission, with supporters saying it restores balance between state and federal authority. Debate included separation-of-powers concerns from members worried about concentrating functions in the legislature; the measure passed 58–10 and will go to the Senate.

Representative Ivory framed Substitute House Bill 131 as a vehicle to institutionalize work already begun under an interbranch council, converting it into a legislative commission to coordinate with like-minded legislatures in other states. "What this bill simply does, representatives, is it takes what we did 2 years ago and makes it a legislative commission... that we then unite with other legislative bodies and state legislative policy makers around the nation to do this same work," Ivory said.

Supporters argued the commission restores a balance in the governing partnership with the federal government and enables states to coordinate on jurisdictional issues; Representative Vanderey said the proposal would help the state "control our own destiny." Members including Representative Chavez Houck and Representative Noel pressed the sponsor on separation-of-powers concerns and the level of executive and judicial branch involvement on related work. Ivory repeatedly emphasized state control of education, quoting historical context: "Education is a matter reserved exclusively to the states." The House passed the bill 58 yes, 10 no.

Floor debate referenced related efforts in other states and national groups; sponsors said the commission is a lower‑cost way to formalize interstate coordination on federalism matters.