Get Full Government Meeting Transcripts, Videos, & Alerts Forever!
Get email alerts on the Alcohol Policy topic
No spam. Unsubscribe anytime.
Senate narrowly approves wide-ranging rewrite of Utah alcohol laws, eliminating mini-bottles and banning brown-bagging
Summary
After hours of debate, the Utah Senate passed Senate Bill 141, a 291-page revision of state alcohol law that ends mini-bottles, phases out brown-bagging, adds metered dispensing, increases certain liquor licenses and funds enforcement; the final Senate vote was 23-2 with phased effective dates.
The Utah Senate voted 23-2 to pass Senate Bill 141, a far-reaching rewrite of the state's alcohol laws that sponsors said would "give better control on consumption because it eliminates brown bagging." Senator Carling, the task-force sponsor, told colleagues the 291-page measure replaces mini-bottles with calibrated dispensing devices and expands limited restaurant and private-club licenses, with special attention to rural areas.
The bill eliminates the mini bottle and phases in new rules: the ban on bringing outside bottles into establishments (so-called "brown-bagging") was set to take effect July 1, 1990, and the mini-bottle phaseout July 1, 1991. Carling said the proposal would allow servers to deliver controlled mixed drinks to tables using metered dispensers that calibrate one-ounce pours, which the task force described as a practical compromise between control and availability.
Sponsors also wrote budget provisions into the bill. The measure includes two targeted appropriations of $150,000 each to the Department of Public Safety and the licensing agency to support enforcement and administration; sponsors said the new license fees are expected to generate about $180,000, leaving a net appropriation of roughly $120,000 in the first year. "The new licenses will bring in a hundred and $80,000 in revenue. Therefore, the $300,000 that's being appropriated is offset by $180,000 in license fees," Senator Carling said.
The task force held extensive outreach before the bill reached the floor: officers said members conducted multiple public hearings across the state and received more than 500 questionnaire responses used to refine the text. Testimony on the floor highlighted competing concerns: proponents argued the bill improved public safety and the state's image for tourists; opponents warned it could harm small, rural taverns and favored stronger dram-shop liability rather than broad changes to dispensing rules.
On charters and limousines, the bill differentiates between overnight- or tour-type buses and short-trip charter buses: open containers can be allowed on outbound legs of round-trip charters but are prohibited on the return leg to reduce the risk of intoxicated driving after disembarkation. The bill also preserves an existing dram-shop cap at industry request, and sponsors entered a journal statement clarifying that dram-shop liability in the bill does not supplant other legal liabilities.
After debate the Senate approved the bill by roll-call vote. Sponsors said the bill includes an acceleration clause that required a two-thirds vote to make parts of the law effective immediately upon the governor's signature so restaurants and licensees could prepare; the Senate recorded sufficient support to transmit the bill to the House.
The measure now proceeds to the Utah House for further consideration. If enacted as written on the floor, the ban on brown-bagging would take effect in mid-1990 and the ban on mini-bottles in mid-1991. Additional technical (scrivener) amendments the floor adopted earlier will be incorporated in the engrossed text before transmission.
