Get Full Government Meeting Transcripts, Videos, & Alerts Forever!
Get email alerts on the Thrift Settlement topic
No spam. Unsubscribe anytime.
Thrift‑settlement tax waiver fails after senators debate fairness and fiscal impact
Summary
Senate rejected SB 83, which would have waived a state income‑tax haircut on collections from the 1988 thrift settlement to preserve an intended 50/50 split for depositors and the state; the motion failed 9–19 amid concerns about unequal treatment and a roughly $459,000 hit to the uniform school fund.
Senate Bill 83, which would have allowed Utah to waive a state corporate income tax claim on collections from the 1988 thrift settlements so proceeds could be shared 50/50 with depositors as originally intended, failed on the floor after sustained debate.
Sponsors argued the waiver would align state law with federal tax treatment and restore what they called the equitable sharing arrangement envisioned during the original settlement. The bill’s fiscal note cited a potential reduction to the Uniform School Fund of about $459,000 in the current year; proponents said that cost was modest relative to the policy objective of honoring the intended split. Opponents said the proposal would amount to renegotiating an earlier settlement, could set an unfair precedent for other corporations with net operating losses, and would be inequitable to Utah taxpayers.
After extensive floor discussion that included estimates of the recoverable assets (sponsors said receivers expected to collect $9–10 million of roughly $12 million outstanding) and back‑and‑forth about whether the 50/50 split was intended to be before or after taxes, the clerk announced the final roll-call: 9 ayes, 19 nays, 1 absent; the bill failed.
