Get Full Government Meeting Transcripts, Videos, & Alerts Forever!
Get email alerts on the Taxation topic
No spam. Unsubscribe anytime.
Senate rejects proposal to extend sales tax to taxi and similar transportation services
Summary
The Utah Senate debated and narrowly rejected SB 205, a bill led by Senator Lyle Hilliard that would have removed exemptions on certain transportation services (including taxis and limousines). Senators split over fairness and impact on low‑income and senior riders; the bill failed 16–13.
Senators debated a proposal to broaden the sales‑tax base by removing exemptions for some transportation services, including taxi and limousine fares, but voted it down after an hour of floor discussion.
Sponsor Senator Lyle Hilliard told colleagues the measure aimed to make the tax base fairer and reduce ‘‘pyramiding’’ of taxes, noting that other services (rental cars, ski lift passes and movie admissions) are already taxed. ‘‘We tax rental cars,’’ he said, ‘‘so . . . you pay sales tax on that.’’ Hilliard argued the state tax commission and tax review commission supported repealing several exemptions.
Opponents warned the change would fall disproportionally on drivers and riders who depend on taxis and similar services. Senator Ward said the proposal risked creating a complex, hard‑to‑administer tax that would ‘‘hurt the low income [and] handicap people’’ and senior residents who rely on cabs for medical appointments and groceries. Other senators said taxing one service while exempting similar ones shows a troubling policy inconsistency.
After floor exchanges about administrative feasibility, fairness across service categories and the size of the projected revenue impact, the roll call showed 16 yeas and 13 nays; the bill did not pass.
The Senate moved on to other business after agreeing to brief Rules Committee activity and scheduling follow‑up meetings. The rules chair said the Senate would consider related sales‑tax bills (including SB 211 and SB 191) in coming floor sessions.
