Get Full Government Meeting Transcripts, Videos, & Alerts Forever!
Get email alerts on the Sb 182 Payroll Deductions topic
No spam. Unsubscribe anytime.
Utah Senate approves bill tightening rules for political payroll deductions by school employees
Summary
The Utah Senate on March 4, 1998, approved Senate Bill 182 after floor debate on whether payroll deductions for political activity should be limited; the measure passed 15–13 and will be sent to the House.
The Utah State Senate voted to pass Senate Bill 182 on March 4, 1998, sending the measure to the House after a close floor vote. President Beatty announced the result: "Senate bill 182 has 15 aye votes, 13 nay votes, and 1 being absent" (vote announced on the floor).
Supporters argued the bill protects equality and clarifies how payroll deductions for political activity are handled. In floor remarks an unidentified senator who opened debate said the bill addressed "freedom of choice" and urged colleagues to review material distributed to members, adding that the Salt Lake Tribune and the state GOP chair had expressed support for the measure. "A lot of times, that Tribune doesn't agree with my positions. But on this one, they believe that it's a principled proposal," the senator said.
Opponents warned the bill singled out certain employee groups and could be unfair. One floor explanation recorded on the roll call said the sponsor or cosponsor had later moved the bill in committee to exclude UPEA/UEA and that the exclusion concerned some members. Another unnamed senator who had signed on as a cosponsor said he nonetheless would vote no, saying he supported the philosophy but opposed what he called an uneven treatment of groups: "I signed on as a cosponsor on this bill because I felt it treated everybody alike... but I vote no on the basis of not being fair in all groups." (floor explanation).
Senators gave short spoken explanations for their votes during roll call; several members referenced concerns about disclosure, school-board election fundraising and whether payroll-based collections made boards effectively collectors of political contributions. The Senate recorded individual ballots during roll call and then transmitted the bill to the House for its consideration.
What happens next: The bill will be sent to the Utah House of Representatives for consideration. Because the Senate vote was close, the House debate will determine whether the measure becomes final or is amended.
Sources: Floor debate and roll-call announcements, Utah State Senate session, March 4, 1998.
