Utah Senate passes workers' compensation change after heated debate over burden of proof
Loading...
Summary
After extended floor debate, the Utah Senate passed Senate Bill 1 62 to limit certain workers' compensation wage benefits where employees knowingly used drugs or alcohol on the job; opponents warned the measure flips the presumption of innocence and would reduce benefits for injured workers and families.
Senators passed Senate Bill 1 62, a proposal to limit wage benefits under Utah's workers' compensation system when an employee's intentional misuse of drugs or alcohol contributed to an on‑the‑job injury.
Sponsor Senator Hallowell introduced the amendment package and said the changes were intended to answer colleagues' questions about scope and wording. Opponents repeatedly urged caution. Senator Hilliard warned the measure “turns around the presumption of guilt and innocence,” saying it reads as "you're guilty until you're proven innocent." He argued that imposing such a burden would punish injured employees and their families by cutting off a key wage replacement at a time of need.
Supporters, including Senator Stevenson, said the bill is about personal accountability on the job. “In those cases where employees are using illegal drugs or . . . other substances inappropriately that contribute to injury on the job, they need to be held accountable,” Stevenson said, adding that other states have adopted similar rules.
Senator Hallowell responded to objections by drawing a distinction between medical benefits and wage payments: "This bill does not take away their doctor's benefit. This bill is only dealing with wages," he said, stressing that medical care under workers' compensation would continue even where wages are reduced.
After roll call, the clerk announced the Senate’s tally as recorded on the floor and the measure was advanced to the House for consideration.
