Get Full Government Meeting Transcripts, Videos, & Alerts Forever!
Get email alerts on the Local Government Constitution topic
No spam. Unsubscribe anytime.
Constitutional amendment to expand local-government powers fails in Senate
Summary
Senate Joint Resolution 5, proposing to amend the state constitution to change how local-government and special-district powers are described, failed to reach the two‑thirds threshold despite passing by majority on the floor.
SALT LAKE CITY — A proposed constitutional amendment to clarify or expand local-government powers, Senate Joint Resolution 5, failed to pass the Utah Senate on Feb. 10 after extended debate.
Supporters argued the amendment would empower municipalities and recognize their autonomy; opponents warned it would permanently enshrine powers in the constitution that properly belong to statutes and could reduce the Legislature’s ability to respond to future problems. "To give these powers away permanently in the constitution is a major mistake," Senator Mansell said during debate.
Floor debate included technical amendments to delete redundant references to "special district(s)" and arguments about whether housing such powers in the constitution was necessary or premature. On final roll call the resolution received 17 ayes, 10 nays and 2 absences — a simple majority but short of the two‑thirds required (20 votes) to place a constitutional amendment before voters — so SJR 5 failed on the floor.
What happens next: Sponsors signaled intent to revisit the measure at a later opportunity, but the amendment will not proceed to a public vote following this failure in the Senate.
