Get Full Government Meeting Transcripts, Videos, & Alerts Forever!
Get email alerts on the Workers Compensation topic
No spam. Unsubscribe anytime.
Senate approves SB119 to change Workers’ Compensation Fund board appointments, amid objections about lost oversight
Summary
The Utah Senate passed SB119, which revises Workers’ Compensation Fund governance and board-appointment procedures. Supporters said the changes preserve the fund’s ability to underwrite out-of-state business; opponents warned the measure removes Senate advice-and-consent and weakens legislative oversight.
The Utah Senate passed Senate Bill 119 on Feb. 7, 2002, changing how the Workers’ Compensation Fund’s board is appointed and clarifying accounting and guarantee-fund provisions.
Sponsor Senator Fulton told the chamber the bill combines guarantee funds and revises the appointment process so an executive-branch official—rather than statutory gubernatorial appointment subject to the Senate’s advice and consent—would formally approve public directors. Fulton said the change is intended to preserve the fund’s federal tax status, stabilize its financial rating and allow limited underwriting outside Utah so the fund can reduce reinsurance costs.
Opponents pressed the sponsor on oversight implications. "If we do this, we're taking away the governor's right to appoint to the board, but we're also taking away the Senate's right to advice and consent on these appointments," a senator said during questioning, arguing the change would remove a legislative check on board appointments. Another senator described the move as damaging to the legislature's oversight role and said it could create the perception of a legislative "end run" to enable the fund to compete outside the state.
Fulton responded that the change followed legal advice from fund attorneys and that intent language committed the fund to remain Utah's carrier of last resort and to maintain IRS compliance. He read the intent language on the floor, saying it was the legislature's understanding that the Workers’ Compensation Fund would preserve its exemption under the Internal Revenue Code and that articles of incorporation would include provisions authorizing an executive-branch official to appoint qualified public directors, subject to oversight by the insurance commissioner.
After discussion, the Senate advanced SB119 to third reading and recorded a roll-call vote. The president announced the tally as 18 ayes and 5 no votes with 6 absent; the bill passed and was referred to the House for further consideration. The Senate also adopted the sponsor’s stated intent language describing the legislature’s expectations for the fund and protections for its IRS status.
What’s next: SB119 will be transmitted to the Utah House for consideration. The bill’s text, the adopted intent language and any changes made in the House will determine whether the board-appointment process is altered as described on the Senate floor.
