Get Full Government Meeting Transcripts, Videos, & Alerts Forever!
Get email alerts on the Mental Health Law topic
No spam. Unsubscribe anytime.
Senate advances third substitute of S.B. 27, tightening standards for involuntary commitment
Summary
After lengthy debate and multiple amendments, the Senate passed the third substitute to S.B. 27 on involuntary commitment standards (defining "serious bodily injury," reliability of hearsay, and procedural safeguards) and sent it to the House. Supporters said it improves protections; critics warned of due‑process concerns.
Senator Blackham, who shepherded the involuntary‑commitment rewrite, told colleagues the third substitute to S.B. 27 reflects extensive interim task‑force work and many negotiated changes. He said the bill tightens and clarifies standards such as "serious bodily injury" and the role of reliable hearsay at early summary hearings.
"We've got to have an understanding," Senator Blackham said, summarizing the process that produced the third substitute. Supporters, including Senator Gladwell, praised added protections and procedural safeguards and argued the revised definitions narrow the bill's scope to people who pose a substantial danger. "We actually have a far better bill than we have ever had in the state of Utah," Gladwell said, citing new safeguards and screening procedures.
Opponents expressed continuing reservations. Senator Stevenson compared predictive evaluations to science‑fiction 'precogs' and said he remained uneasy about foretelling dangerous behavior. Senator Evans raised concerns about specific wording and asked for technical changes at the lines identified on the floor; those changes were discussed and, where appropriate, modified or withdrawn.
The Senate debated admissible reliable hearsay and whether standards at summary hearings would be appropriately constrained; Senator Hilliard explained that courts are assigned to determine whether out‑of‑court statements meet the 'reliable hearsay' standards used in other preliminary contexts.
Final action: After debate and a flurry of amendment offers, the Senate adopted the third substitute and recorded the final roll-call tally sending the measure to the House for further consideration.
Next steps: The bill will be transmitted to the House; senators indicated some remained watchful about implementation details governing commitment thresholds and the handling of vulnerable populations.
