Get Full Government Meeting Transcripts, Videos, & Alerts Forever!
Get email alerts on the Public Health Smoking topic
No spam. Unsubscribe anytime.
Utah Senate rejects bill to ban smoking in private clubs and taverns
Summary
After extended floor debate on public-health and freedom arguments, the Senate voted 13–16 to defeat SB 77, a measure that would have removed a Clean Air Act exemption for private social clubs and taverns and extended workplace smoke-free protections to their employees.
The Utah State Senate on Feb. 14 defeated Senate Bill 77, a proposal to remove a statewide exemption in the Utah Indoor Clean Air Act for private clubs and taverns and make those workplaces smoke-free. Sponsor Senator Jonathon Wadhams (introduced on the floor) and backers argued the change would protect workers and patrons from secondhand smoke and reduce public health costs, while opponents said the measure carried too many exemptions and infringed on personal and local choices.
Senator Wadhams framed the bill as a public-health measure, citing state estimates of smoking-related costs to taxpayers and Medicaid — and noting national and international trends toward smoke-free bars and restaurants. He told colleagues many workers in private clubs and taverns want smoke-free workplaces and cited sampling of local venues showing few currently non-smoking establishments.
Opponents raised concerns about the bill's effectiveness given carved-out exemptions and the proper role of state versus local decision-making. Senator Ron Allen, explaining his vote, said he supports clean air but was unconvinced this bill, as written, would achieve meaningful protections and preferred voluntary local measures for now. Other senators described personal and constituency-based objections.
The Senate recorded the final roll-call as 13 yes, 16 no and 0 absent; with that count SB 77 failed and will be filed (no further Senate action recorded in this session). The presiding officer then moved the body to other business.
The debate included multiple floor explanations of vote choices and citations of public-health studies and local business concerns. The most recent procedural outcome is the bill's failure in the Senate; no amendment or scheduling for reconsideration was announced before the recess.
