Get Full Government Meeting Transcripts, Videos, & Alerts Forever!
Get email alerts on the Hate Crimes topic
No spam. Unsubscribe anytime.
Senate passes substitute hate-crimes bill focusing on community harm
Summary
The Utah Senate passed a substitute to House Bill 90 that raises misdemeanor penalties by one level and makes community harm an aggravating factor at sentencing; the measure passed unanimously in the Senate and will return to the House for signature.
The Utah Senate on Feb. 28 passed a substitute for House Bill 90 that reframes how courts treat hate-motivated offenses, emphasizing the public harm caused by such crimes rather than a prescriptive list of protected groups.
Sponsor Senator Karen Hale told the Senate the substitute increases misdemeanor penalties by one level "rather than imposing any felony penalty" and directs judges and the Board of Pardons to consider "the degree to which the offense is likely to incite community unrest or cause members of the community to reasonably fear for their physical safety," language she said was taken from the U.S. Supreme Court opinion Mitchell v. Wisconsin.
Supporters, including Senator Wadhams, said the change focuses on the effects of an offense—its ripple effects on communities—making sentencing guidance clearer for judges and the parole board. Senator Aaron described the substitute as the result of lengthy negotiations with prosecutors, law-enforcement and community leaders.
Opponents said they had long debated enhancements tied to motive. The record shows the Senate adopted the substitute and passed House Bill 90 under suspension of the rules; the clerk reported a final Senate vote of 29 yes, 0 nay, 0 absent. The bill will be signed by the president in open session and returned to the House for its signature and further action.
The measure moves away from enlarging certain misdemeanors directly into felonies and instead provides sentencing authorities explicit aggravating factors to consider that reflect community impact.
