Get Full Government Meeting Transcripts, Videos, & Alerts Forever!
Get email alerts on the Education Budget topic
No spam. Unsubscribe anytime.
Senate approves substitute House Bill 2 to backfill K–12 cuts with one‑time funds, amid sharp debate
Summary
The Utah Senate passed the first substitute to House Bill 2 on March 11, 2009, approving one‑time federal and state backfill for public schools while deferring larger structural funding decisions. Lawmakers split over cuts to teacher grants, charter funding and the long‑term budget outlook.
Senate President and education leaders moved House Bill 2, a substituted minimum school program budget measure, for final passage after extended floor debate on March 11, 2009. Sponsor Senator Gregory Stevenson said the measure combines several amendments to preserve base funding while using one‑time resources to soften reductions.
The bill reduces uniform school fund contributions by roughly $144,797,000 against the prior FY 2009 appropriation but provides about $293,500,000 in one‑time revenue, Stevenson said, noting roughly $86,000,000 would come from the Uniform School Fund and about $207,000,000 from federal stimulus monies. The substitute also funds enrollment growth for an estimated 13,494 new students, leaves the WPU at $2,577 and provides roughly $22.5 million for capital outlay support, the sponsor said.
"We are trimming education spending considerably, but we are backfilling most of the reductions," Senator Stevenson said on the floor. "This is one‑time money; districts must plan for the cliff when the backfill ends." He urged school districts to treat much of the aid as temporary.
Opponents and questioning senators focused on the distribution of cuts and whether the bill shifts resources toward charter schools. Senator John Goodfellow and others pressed whether the bill shifts local replacement obligations or otherwise robs district funding. Senator Stevenson responded that the amendment retained the 25 percent local / 75 percent state split for charter growth funding and added a procedural change tying preliminary charter approvals to a later final review, intended to avoid premature commitments by new charter organizers.
Senator Bell raised concerns that a $77 million reduction in the Quality Teacher Block Grant could be allocated disproportionately toward classroom teachers or other payroll categories at local discretion; the sponsor and committee members said the reductions were structured to maximize local flexibility and did not mandate how districts would allocate cuts.
The Senate voted to pass the first substitute House Bill 2 under suspension of the rules. The roll call recorded 15 yea votes, 9 nay votes and 5 absent. The measure was returned to the House for its action.
The bill carries significant short‑term relief but leaves long‑term structural funding choices unresolved; sponsors and committee chairs warned school districts to expect the one‑time backfill to expire and to budget accordingly.
