Get Full Government Meeting Transcripts, Videos, & Alerts Forever!
Get email alerts on the Court Fees topic
No spam. Unsubscribe anytime.
Senate passes bill to double small‑claims filing fees; opponents warn of access barriers
Summary
The Utah Senate approved SB176 to raise small‑claims filing fees (e.g., $45→$90 under typical thresholds) after debate over access for pro se litigants. Supporters framed it as a modest user fee to shore up justice‑system resources; opponents said it risks denying low‑income litigants a quick forum.
The Utah Senate voted to advance Senate Bill 176, a measure to raise filing fees in small‑claims court, after floor debate over whether the increase would impede access to justice.
Senator Greiner, sponsor of the bill, said testimony in committee showed court funding pressures and that ‘‘you have a bill to increase the filing fees in small claims court only,’’ with many fees being doubled in the common under‑$2,000 category (example cited on the floor: $45 to $90). He argued the increase would align Utah with neighboring states and help justice courts.
Senator Urquhart, speaking in opposition, warned higher fees could erode a ‘‘precious little island’’ of access that pro se filers rely on: "We need to leave this little island alone," he said, noting legal help is otherwise costly.
Supporters including Senator McCoy acknowledged that fees alone do not fully fund the justice system but said modest increases can help cover administrative costs; Greiner called the proposed $90 fee "probably pretty reasonable." The measure passed on a roll call and was placed at the bottom of the third‑reading calendar with a tally of 15 yeas, 11 nays and 3 absent.
What’s next: SB176 will await third reading; if passed, the fee schedule and implementing guidance will be set by statute and administrative rule.
