Get Full Government Meeting Transcripts, Videos, & Alerts Forever!
Get email alerts on the Budget Process topic
No spam. Unsubscribe anytime.
Senate advances changes to budget submission rules; HB488 would let governor optionally submit a full budget
Summary
Lawmakers approved House Bill 488, which gives the governor discretion to submit a full or modified budget rather than requiring a full proposal, and debated implications for transparency and the Legislature's role in setting priorities.
Senator Niederhauser told the Senate that House Bill 488 would alter Utah's base-budget procedures by allowing the governor to "elect to submit a budget proposal or may be able to just provide a budget proposal with changes from the previous year," giving the executive branch more flexibility in how it presents its fiscal plan.
Supporters said the change would reduce the burden on governors and staff who sometimes spend months preparing a budget that is ultimately rewritten by the Legislature. "The governor has discretion in submitting the budget rather than the obligation to do so," Niederhauser said during floor debate.
Opponents warned the optional approach could undercut the Legislature's ability to begin the session with a clear set of proposals. Senator Davis said a governor's formal proposal is an important starting point for the three-branch budgeting process and cautioned that making submission optional could allow a political executive to "step aside" in a campaign year and avoid providing a comprehensive proposal.
Senator Hilliard and others noted the bill responds to concerns raised by Ron Bigelow at the Governor's Office of Planning and Budget (GOPB) about the time required to prepare a full budget; supporters said consensus revenue figures would still be available to inform negotiations.
After floor debate and a motion by the sponsor, HB488 was read for second and third time and placed up for final passage; the President announced the bill was received with 18 yea votes, 10 nay votes and 1 absent and will be returned to the House for the Speaker's signature.
The Legislature recorded the change and will return the enrolled bill to the House; any administrative details about how the governor's optional submission would be implemented are left to GOPB and future rulemaking or interbranch practice.
Next steps: HB488 is enrolled and transmitted for the House Speaker's signature, after which the enrolled bill will be returned to the President for filing and any implementing guidance would be developed by the Governor's Office of Planning and Budget and the Legislature.
