Get Full Government Meeting Transcripts, Videos, & Alerts Forever!
Get email alerts on the Education Class Size topic
No spam. Unsubscribe anytime.
Senate approves class-size caps and accountability language after amendment
Summary
After extended debate and several amendments, the Utah Senate voted to advance Senate Bill 31 — a package that sets caps for kindergarten–3rd-grade class sizes and ties incremental funding to districts that meet reporting and cap requirements. The measure passed as amended and was placed on the third-reading calendar.
Senate Bill 31, a measure that would cap kindergarten through third-grade class sizes and tie incremental funding to districts that meet those caps, cleared the Senate on motion after amendment and was placed at the bottom of the third-reading calendar.
The bill’s sponsor, Senator Morgan, said the amendment enshrines caps and accountability in statute and phases implementation to limit immediate cost. "This is just common sense that fewer students in a classroom allows for more 1 on 1 time with the teacher," Morgan said, urging colleagues to support the amendment that the fiscal analyst estimated would reduce the first-year fiscal note to about $3.6 million.
Opponents questioned funding and hidden costs. Senator Bramble said he supported the policy goal but warned about affordability and existing spending: "If a hundred million doesn't get us there, perhaps we need to understand how 3,000,000 would," he said, arguing a mandate without sufficient funding may not achieve the intended results. Senator Okerlund said the bill's costs for small and rural schools were unclear and said she was not convinced enough funding was tied to the mandate.
Senator Thatcher and others urged caution over the long-term fiscal commitment. "The largest concern that I have is the amount of money that this is going to tie up each year," Thatcher said, asking how the Legislature would prioritize funding in tight budget years.
Supporters stressed accountability and a phased approach that would allow kindergarten to be addressed first, and said the amendment included language tying access to incremental class-size funding to demonstrated compliance and plans. Senator Romero said the measure "provides accountability" and cited support from the Utah School Boards Association and the Superintendents Association.
The Senate debated multiple amendments on caps, phase-in, and funding eligibility. After adopting sponsor and committee amendments, the Senate recorded the final roll call: 18 yeas, 9 nays, 2 absent; the measure will proceed to third reading as amended.
Next steps: SB 31 will appear on the Senate’s third-reading calendar for final passage consideration; the enacted timetable and appropriations for full implementation will depend on later budget decisions and the Legislature’s appropriation process.
