Get Full Government Meeting Transcripts, Videos, & Alerts Forever!
Get email alerts on the Child Welfare topic
No spam. Unsubscribe anytime.
Senate restores 'clear and convincing' standard for removing foster children from relatives
Summary
After floor debate and a sponsor change, the Senate reinstated the 'clear and convincing evidence' standard in HB241 so the Division of Child and Family Services must meet that higher burden before removing a child placed with a relative; the bill passed as amended.
Senators considered House Bill 241, which modifies the process for removing foster children from relatives. The bill’s sponsor explained it would require the Division of Child and Family Services to produce clear and convincing evidence before removing a child placed with a relative foster parent. A House amendment had changed that standard to a preponderance of the evidence; on the Senate floor Senator Valentine and others successfully moved to reinstate the higher clear-and-convincing standard.
Supporters argued family placements should not be overturned lightly and that relatives are often the best placement option for foster children; opponents cautioned that in some cases agencies need flexibility but many senators noted the equity and stability benefits of the stricter standard. Senator Robles and others said the change aligns with a protective approach for children and families.
Senate action on the amended bill recorded 20 yea votes, 1 nay and multiple absentees; the bill passed and will proceed to third reading processing steps.
