Get Full Government Meeting Transcripts, Videos, & Alerts Forever!
Get email alerts on the HB81 Sales Tax topic
No spam. Unsubscribe anytime.
Senate advances sales-tax hold-harmless fix after heated debate over 15-year extension
Summary
Senators approved First Substitute House Bill 81 on second reading after extended debate about extending a 0.2% optional local tax for two cities. Supporters described the change as finality for negotiated redevelopment plans; opponents said it effectively extends a local tax and would disadvantage some retailers.
The Utah Senate on Feb. 29 debated First Substitute House Bill 81, a measure altering the phase-out of a historical 'hold harmless' sales-tax allocation and authorizing a 0.2% optional sales-and-use tax extension for two municipalities for a 15-year period.
Sponsor Senator Bramble told the body the substitute reached a negotiated settlement with the two remaining affected cities and the House sponsor to provide finality for the allocation change. He said the extension was negotiated to allow South Salt Lake and Riverdale to proceed with planned redevelopment financing, including potential RDA bond issuance.
Opponents, led by Senator Stevenson, said the measure effectively prolongs an additional local tax beyond the sunset date that would have otherwise ended in 2016, disadvantaging retailers in those communities on large-ticket items and constituting a de facto tax extension. Senator Valentine said he intended to enter intent language into the Senate journal to document the terms of a 'gentleman's agreement' that the extension would end when the RDA bonds were paid off.
After extended discussion and questions from multiple senators, the Senate voted on second reading. The clerk reported 16 yeas, 9 nays and 4 absent; the bill proceeds toward third reading. Senator Bramble said he preferred a shorter phase-out but accepted the negotiated 15-year term as a compromise to achieve finality across municipalities and to avoid repeated extensions that have characterized the issue historically.
Key details: - The bill would extend a 0.2 percentage-point differential for two cities beyond the prior phase-out date (the sponsor said the differential would otherwise have ended in Feb. 2016). - Sponsor named the affected municipalities as South Salt Lake and Riverdale on the floor and said the cities agreed not to seek further extensions beyond the negotiated 15-year period.
Sponsor quote: "We now have an agreement from the remaining 2 cities ... if we give them a 15 year extension of the 2 tenths of a percent, that there will be finality."
Opposition quote: "If we don't do anything right now, the additional tax will end in 2016, and we ought to let it end in 2016, rather than extending it for another 15 years," said Senator Stevenson.
Next steps: The sponsor said he would accept intent language on the record to clarify the terms; the bill will face a third-reading vote on the Senate calendar.
