Get Full Government Meeting Transcripts, Videos, & Alerts Forever!
Get email alerts on the Public Health Child Safety topic
No spam. Unsubscribe anytime.
Utah Senate approves law making smoking in vehicles with children a secondary offense after heated debate
Summary
The Utah Senate passed House Bill 13, making it a secondary offense to smoke in a vehicle with a child 15 or younger (fine up to $45, waivable with cessation class), after a lengthy floor debate about government overreach and child safety. The measure passed 16–13 following a call of the Senate.
The Utah Senate on the afternoon calendar passed House Bill 13, which makes it a secondary offense to smoke in a vehicle carrying a child 15 years or younger and authorizes a fine up to $45, waivable if the violator enrolls in a smoking‑cessation class. The bill’s sponsor, identified in the transcript as Senator Osman, framed the measure as child‑safety legislation, saying it "is about putting the rights of the child ahead of the personal property rights of any adult."
Supporters argued secondhand smoke concentrations are far higher inside a vehicle and that children cannot escape the environment. Senator Christiansen told colleagues the bill seeks to "protect that child from a form of abuse," citing medical testimony and support from health and child‑advocacy organizations. Senator Vickers, who supported the bill, said he evaluated it "from a standpoint of a health professional" and concluded it "has a potential to improve the health of kids."
Opponents said the measure improperly intrudes on private family life and sets a dangerous precedent of government overreach. Senator Dayton said he could not support the bill because it "interfer[es] with what we are doing in our families," and Senator Jenkins warned that the measure criminalizes otherwise law‑abiding people. Several senators raised concerns the bill would be symbolic and inconsistent with broader state policy on tobacco.
Because the vote was expected to be close, Senator Osman sought a call of the Senate to ensure all members were present. After members explained their votes and some described personal experiences with secondhand smoke, the Senate recorded the final tally: 16 yea, 13 nay. The President announced that House Bill 13 "having received 16 yay votes, 13 nay votes ... passes" and would be signed and sent to the House for the Speaker’s signature.
The measure is a secondary offense (not a primary traffic stop), carries a maximum $45 fine that may be waived if the defendant completes a cessation class, and applies to children 15 and younger. The sponsor and several senators said they were open to future amendments and emphasized the bill’s limited scope.
Next step: the measure will be returned to the House for formal concurrence and the Speaker’s signature.
