Get Full Government Meeting Transcripts, Videos, & Alerts Forever!
Get email alerts on the Family Law Adoption topic
No spam. Unsubscribe anytime.
Senate Passes Measure Letting Grandparents Seek Visitation When Child Is Adopted by Relatives
Summary
The Senate passed a third-substitute (as amended) of H.B. 418 clarifying that grandparents may petition for visitation in certain adoptive-placement situations involving relative adoptions; debate focused on potential policy shift, constitutional concerns, and impacts on adoptive families.
Senator Harper led the Senate through third substitute H.B. 418, which clarifies existing code to allow grandparents standing to petition for visitation when a child who had parental rights terminated is adopted by a relative. The Senate accepted an amendment to replace the phrase "relatives" with "grandparents" in the title and to ensure the provision applies to visitation requests in narrowly defined circumstances.
Senators expressed a range of views. Senator Weiler and others warned the measure represents a "major policy shift," arguing it could erode protections for adoptive parents and deter potential adoptive couples; Weiler read constituent concerns that opening judicial petitions to grandparents could complicate adoptive placements. Sponsors and supporters, including Senator Reid and Senator Matson, said the bill simply provides limited standing so courts can consider kinship options and preserve family ties when appropriate. Several senators stressed judicial discretion: the bill gives grandparents the ability to petition but leaves final determinations to judges.
The Senate passed the substitute and the bill was filed for process (clerk recorded the result as sent to staff for filing after a roll call reported 13 yay votes; three absences were noted). Floor debate emphasized the limited applicability (relative adoptions) and the role of the court to protect adoptive parents' constitutional rights.
