Get Full Government Meeting Transcripts, Videos, & Alerts Forever!
Get email alerts on the Elections School Board topic
No spam. Unsubscribe anytime.
Senate adopts third substitute to make select school-board races partisan; floor debate centers on Hatch Act and local impact
Summary
The Senate approved a third substitute to SB 104 that raises the population threshold for partisan local school-board races to 50,000 and clarifies the state school-board election remains partisan. Debate focused on whether shifting local races to partisan status would trigger Hatch Act restrictions for federally funded employees and on the broader implications for local governance.
The Utah Senate approved a third substitute to Senate Bill 104 after extended floor debate that centered on the scope and local consequences of making some school-board contests partisan.
Senator Jackson, sponsor of the bill, said research and counsel confirmed that unaffiliated voters can run in partisan elections and that federal employees may be prohibited from running in partisan elections under the Hatch Act. Senator Vickers described the third substitute as a compromise that raises the district-size threshold for partisan local elections from 20,000 to 50,000 and clarifies that the state school-board election is partisan; he said the change would reduce the number of affected districts to about four large districts (Alpine, Davis, Granite, Jordan).
Opponents, including Senator Escamilla, warned that the Hatch Act can apply not only to federal employees but to employees of entities that receive federal funds. "The Hatch Act... applies to anyone that works in an agency that's federally funded that gets money from the federal government," Escamilla said on the floor, arguing partisan designation could disqualify many local employees and volunteers from serving. Senator Thatcher and others described concerns about nonpartisan contests being shaped by organized outside interests and urged partisan contests to improve vetting and transparency in large districts.
The Senate conducted a roll call and the third substitute passed with 19 yea, 8 nay, and 2 absent. The bill will be transmitted to the House. Senators on both sides urged follow-up work to clarify Hatch Act consequences and to consider options for state and local oversight or referenda.
Procedural note: the floor voted on the third substitute and then on final passage; several senators offered explanations of votes before the clerk announced the final tally.
