Get Full Government Meeting Transcripts, Videos, & Alerts Forever!
Get email alerts on the Affordable Housing topic
No spam. Unsubscribe anytime.
Senate approves third substitute to SB 34 to tighten housing-planning requirements in some communities
Summary
After hours of debate, the Utah Senate passed the third substitute to Senate Bill 34, a planning-focused bill that adjusts affordable-housing and transit-area coordination rules for certain cities and metro townships; the measure passed 20–9 and will go to the House.
The Utah Senate on the floor passed the third substitute to Senate Bill 34, a measure that modifies local planning standards tied to transit corridors and tax-increment financing, by a roll-call vote of 20–9.
Senator Andrick, sponsor of the Senate substitute, said the changes are largely technical but increase requirements in larger communities and where major transportation corridors exist. "This is not a silver bullet," Andrick said, "but it's a first really good step." He argued the bill aligns previous transportation and planning work and would better coordinate local growth with transportation dollars.
Opponents voiced concerns the bill would do little in practice and raised fiscal and priority questions. "I hate this bill," Senator Fillmore said, calling it confusing and warning that it appeared to offer a long list of options that most cities already use. Senator Hilliard said he would vote no again and asked whether funding for the bill would take precedence over Medicaid expansion; he emphasized the need to be selective about general-fund spending.
Sponsors responded with fiscal clarifications. According to the floor exchange, the net fiscal impact is $24,000,000, described as $4,000,000 of ongoing costs and $20,000,000 one-time, and analysts explained the accounting that led to a larger-seeming total. The bill links program eligibility to certain transportation financing (tax-increment financing or TIF) and was described by its backers as a way to make transportation investments and housing plans coordinate more efficiently.
Senator Andrick emphasized stakeholder work on the bill, saying it included months of meetings with cities, towns and the League of Cities and Towns and urging colleagues to treat the measure as an incremental tool. "We're going to double our population in the next 30 years," Andrick said, arguing better planning will avoid wasted infrastructure spending.
The Senate approved the third substitute and passed the bill; the clerk announced the final vote as 20 ayes and 9 nays. The bill will be transmitted to the House for further consideration.
