Get Full Government Meeting Transcripts, Videos, & Alerts Forever!
Get email alerts on the Distracted Driving topic
No spam. Unsubscribe anytime.
Utah House approves hands‑free driving law after debate over evidence and narrow exemptions
Summary
The House passed HB101 on Feb. 24, 2020, making handheld cell‑phone use while driving a primary enforceable offense with limited exemptions; supporters said it gives law enforcement an enforceable tool, while opponents urged more evidence that hands‑free driving is safer. The bill passed 40‑32 and moves to the Senate.
The Utah House of Representatives on Feb. 24 approved House Bill 101, a hands‑free distracted‑driving law that makes manually manipulating a handheld wireless device while operating a moving motor vehicle a primary enforceable offense, with narrowly drawn exemptions for ham radio and two‑way radio operators.
Representative Carol Moss, the bill sponsor, said the measure “gives our law enforcement officers . . . the tool to help us” and argued the law is clear and enforceable: “if you're holding a cell phone, you're violating the law.” Moss also said the bill does not ban talking on phones or block parents from answering urgent calls, and noted existing enforcement gaps from prior statutes.
Opponents questioned whether the statute will reduce crashes. Representative Robertson said cellphone use accounts for a minority of distracted‑driving cases and urged caution in adopting a law without strong evidence distinguishing handheld from hands‑free risk. Representative Musselman echoed that some peer‑reviewed studies show little difference between hands‑free and handheld use, and warned cultural change — not law alone — may be necessary.
Supporters countered with law‑enforcement and public‑safety arguments and personal anecdotes of near‑misses and collisions. Representative Watkins described a recent crash involving a child allegedly struck by a driver who admitted phone use, and Representative Potter and others recounted personal collisions they blamed on distracted drivers.
The House adopted an amendment offered by Moss to add exemptions for ham radio operators and certain industries that rely on two‑way radios. The sponsor clarified that the bill's language applies only to operating moving vehicles; a driver stopped at a red light is not violating the bill’s prohibition.
After extended debate and summation, the House approved HB101, 40 yeas to 32 nays. The bill will be transmitted to the Senate for further consideration.
The House record shows supporters pointed to improved enforceability compared with prior statutes and endorsements from groups such as the Utah Highway Patrol and the Utah PTA; opponents emphasized mixed research findings and cautioned against creating new traffic stops without clear safety gains.
