Get Full Government Meeting Transcripts, Videos, & Alerts Forever!
Get email alerts on the Initiative Reform topic
No spam. Unsubscribe anytime.
House approves measure to raise threshold for statewide tax initiatives; companion constitutional resolution sent to voters
Summary
The House passed HB 284 (initiative amendments) and companion HJR 14 to place a constitutional amendment on the ballot raising the approval threshold for statewide tax-increase initiatives (sponsor discussed 60% threshold and added transparency requirements). Both passed the House 54–20 and will proceed to the Senate or the ballot process.
The Utah House on Feb. 7–8 passed House Bill 284, which would change the rules for statewide initiatives that increase taxes, and approved a companion constitutional proposal, HJR 14, to send the question to voters. Both measures passed the House by a vote of 54–20.
Sponsor Representative Kyle framed the package as protecting taxpayers and increasing transparency, saying the bill requires initiative proponents to disclose ‘‘where the proposed law will be funded’’ and the sources and amounts of any new revenues. Floor debate made explicit that the proposal would raise the required approval threshold for tax-increase initiatives; several supporters referred to a 60% threshold as the target majority.
Opponents warned the measures would curtail popular participation in budgeting choices. Representative Ward said the change ‘‘shaves off in a significant way the legislative power that we share with the people of Utah’’ and urged caution about reducing citizens’ ability to propose and pass laws. Representative Daley-Provost and others raised the 2018 Medicaid expansion as an example of an initiative that passed with a simple majority and said making future initiatives harder to pass could alter long-standing civic practice.
Backers, including Representative Snyder and others, argued that a higher threshold validates initiatives that impose taxes and helps ensure broad, statewide support, especially across rural and urban areas. Representative Gracious told colleagues the measure ‘‘ensuring that the true majority of the people support policy to increase their taxes’’ was an appropriate standard.
Both HB 284 and HJR 14 passed the House and will proceed as prescribed by constitutional and legislative procedures: HB 284 will go to the Senate for consideration; HJR 14, if ultimately approved in both chambers and by other procedural steps, would place the constitutional question before voters.
