Get Full Government Meeting Transcripts, Videos, & Alerts Forever!
Get email alerts on the Employee Benefits topic
No spam. Unsubscribe anytime.
Council approves insurance carrier change and HSA compromise after debate on employee costs and levy impact
Summary
After extended discussion about plan design, employee out‑of‑pocket costs and budget effects, council approved staff’s recommendation to change dental and health plans and adopted a compromise on HSA contributions intended to lower the city’s levy impact while offsetting employee costs.
Council members debated recommended changes to 2025 health and dental insurance plans and the level of city HSA contributions, balancing savings to the general fund against increased employee out‑of‑pocket exposure.
Staff presented a plan (referred to as the Smart Plan/option 3) that would raise some deductibles but produce estimated savings to the general fund of $51,581; staff also presented dental proposals and recommended switching dental carriers to HealthPartners, quoted as a roughly 12% decrease in rates and an estimated dental savings of $12,852. Combining health plan changes, HSA adjustments and dental savings, staff said the three moves together would yield about $19,970 in annual savings for 2025.
Council members asked whether employees would face higher out‑of‑pocket costs under the new plan and how many employees use city insurance (staff reported roughly 49–50 of about 52 employees use the city plan). After an initial motion failed, the council negotiated a compromise on HSA contributions and approved a motion to accept the insurance changes with an adjusted HSA contribution (single: $11.25; family: $2,250) to give employees more options while capturing net savings for the city.
Direct quote from staff on savings: “It’s $19,970 of savings putting the 3 together,” staff said when summarizing the combined impact.
Why it matters: Changes to carrier choice, deductibles and HSA contributions affect employee take‑home pay, recruiting/retention and the city’s budget and levy calculations. The record shows council members weighing competitiveness for hiring against taxpayer impact.
Next step: Staff will communicate the approved changes to the insurer and proceed with open enrollment materials for employees; the HSA contribution and plan changes will be implemented per HR timelines for 2025 open enrollment.
