Rutland listers hear property grievances from Ingrid and Paul Gallo over McKinley properties

The Town of Rutland listers heard grievances July 23 from Ingrid and Paul Gallo about assessments on two McKinley Avenue properties. The Gallos told the listers they paid $230,000 for 24 McKinley and provided a 106‑page inspection from Moose River Environmental Lab describing structural problems including cut rafter tails, removed upstairs fixtures and a torn floor system. They said the property remains on a private well and on‑site septic though a city water stub has been brought to the road but not connected.

The Gallos said they have applied for permits with Vermont Fire and Safety and the town to create a one‑bedroom unit upstairs, which they estimated would cost about $75,000, and that their immediate priority is to have the unit occupied by fall to deter trespassing. Listers said they would copy and keep the Gallos’ documents and scheduled a site visit so staff can inspect the property and verify condition and any changes relevant to valuation.

At the same meeting a speaker representing another McKinley property raised neighborhood concerns about a nearby larger municipal building that has reduced sight lines, increased truck traffic and a new police presence, including holding cells. Listers reminded attendees that assessments are set based on conditions as of April 1, 2024, and that evidence of material changes in use, occupancy or traffic can be considered in future inspections.

The listers told the Gallos they will review submitted materials, make a site visit, and notify them of findings within seven days of the hearing. No formal change to any assessment was announced at the meeting.