Get Full Government Meeting Transcripts, Videos, & Alerts Forever!
Get email alerts on the Addressing And Emergency Response topic
No spam. Unsubscribe anytime.
Committee denies petitions to retain South Deer Lake Circle and Shady Grove Shores addresses
Summary
After public comment and testimony from first responders, a Polk County committee found petitioners did not meet ordinance requirements showing historic names would not hinder emergency response and voted to deny the petitions; the denial will be forwarded to the County Board.
Polk County committee members voted to deny two petitions asking that the county retain the historic names South Deer Lake Circle and Shady Grove Shores instead of converting them to the county’s grid numbering system. The committee concluded petitioners had not demonstrated the change would not aid or impede first responders, as required by county ordinance.
The decision followed public comment from residents who said renaming would be costly and would erase local history. “Changing our address to 130 … requires all of us to change our legal documents, our wills, insurance information, and other bills,” said resident Noelle Standard, who said she’s lived on South Deer Lake Circle for 35 years. Another resident, Mary Sinclair Prezich, criticized the county’s communication and urged the committee to allow dual addresses or modify the ordinance so residents could keep heritage names.
County staff explained that South Deer Lake Circle contains multiple alpha-suffixed addresses (seven separate A suffixes) and that the petitioners did not include evidence demonstrating retention would not aid emergency services. Corporation counsel Joe Loso told the committee the written findings shared with the panel were advisory: the committee must make its own factual findings under the ordinance and either grant the exception or deny it based on the evidence.
Sheriff’s office representatives and other first responders urged the committee to keep the grid system for clarity and efficiency, noting that newer, nonlocal emergency personnel may not know private road names and that GPS outages can limit reliance on mapping apps. “The grid system does work, does make it more efficient for us to find addresses,” a sheriff’s representative said.
The committee first considered a motion to approve the petitions with a recommendation to the County Board but that motion failed on a roll-call vote. Members then voted to deny and dismiss the petitions for lack of compliance with the ordinance’s evidentiary standard. The committee directed that the denial be forwarded to the County Board for final action.
The committee’s written findings will accompany the recommendation, and counsel noted the committee could propose ordinance modifications at a later date if members want more flexibility for dual signage or other local accommodations.
