Get Full Government Meeting Transcripts, Videos, & Alerts Forever!
Get email alerts on the Environment Water Quality topic
No spam. Unsubscribe anytime.
Residents urge Santa Rosa County to seek injunctions and stronger penalties over red‑clay discharges and erosion
Summary
Multiple residents and environmental advocates told the county on Dec. 9 that recent development has deposited up to four feet of red clay in Annie's Basin and Mulat Bayou, producing fish kills and navigation problems; speakers called existing fines insufficient and asked the board to require developer‑paid remediation and consider injunctions.
Pam Mitchell, vice president of Safe Blackwater River, told the Santa Rosa County commission at the Dec. 9 public forum that core samples taken by the Florida Department of Environmental Protection showed as much as "4 feet" of red clay deposited in Annie's Basin by nearby development, and said regulators had assessed about $75,000 in fines. "If you're building a hundred houses and selling those houses for 300‑plus thousand dollars each, $75,000 is a drop in the bucket," Mitchell said, and urged the board to require developers to pay for remediation rather than leave taxpayers to cover future cleanup.
Neighbor and longtime resident Jerry Cooley described photos of recent deposits as "one of the worst environmental photos I've ever seen" and characterized the work as an "unpermitted illicit discharge in violation of the state federal Clean Water Act and the federal Clean Water Act." Cooley asked the commission to seek an injunction to force remediation and recommended that fines be set at the estimated cost of cleanup rather than the comparatively small penalties described by speakers.
Chris Curb of Flood Defenders said county codes enforcement and inspection capacity were inadequate to prevent repeated erosion and illicit discharges, recommended more trained stormwater inspectors, and urged that local enforcement be aligned with state stormwater and MS4 requirements. Arthur Hauck and other Avalon Beach residents reported property damage and loss of habitat after nearby clearing for housing and road work along Damon Drive.
Speakers linked the Mulat/Annie's Basin complaints to a pattern of permitted and unpermitted clearing elsewhere in the county, noted fish kills and sedimentation that have reduced navigability in some channels, and suggested that county staff and state agencies (FDEP) should require remediation bonds or higher fines to deter repeat violations.
County staff acknowledged the complaints during the operations presentation and moved multiple items to the upcoming Thursday agenda for formal consideration; staff also said they would follow up with affected residents. The commission did not take a recorded vote on enforcement policy at the Dec. 9 meeting; speakers asked for stronger, developer‑funded remediation and for the board to consider injunctions where violations are documented.
The county’s next formal opportunity to act on consent and related enforcement items is the Thursday meeting where staff has moved several items for final action. Residents asked the commission to pursue immediate, cost‑based fines and legal remedies and to coordinate with FDEP and other state authorities to ensure remediation occurs.
