Get Full Government Meeting Transcripts, Videos, & Alerts Forever!
Get email alerts on the Criminal Justice topic
No spam. Unsubscribe anytime.
House circles bill on juror eligibility after debate over disruption and reintegration
Summary
Lawmakers voted to 'circle' (postpone) a bill that would affect juror eligibility for people with past convictions after floor debate about disruption to juror summons and reintegration; supporters said more time was needed to resolve details.
The Utah House voted on Jan. 24 to circle a bill that would affect juror eligibility for people with past convictions, postponing further action so sponsors can refine language and address members’ concerns.
Representative Thurston argued the practical burden of jury service on people with past convictions: “when we call people to jury duty, it’s disruptive…you have to take the day off work…And to require people be part of a system that not only now requires you to disclose publicly your past laundry, we’re also disrupting your life for something that’s not gonna result in you being on a jury anyway,” he said on the floor. Thurston said prosecutors and defense attorneys create practical barriers that make actual jury service unlikely for such individuals.
Representative Fitzsimano moved to circle the bill, saying more time was needed to work out details. The sponsor and other members supported the motion, with Representative Ballard saying the question can be emotional and that the body should resolve concerns and obtain an accurate count before restoring some rights to reintegrated citizens. The presiding officer put the motion to a voice vote and the motion passed; the bill was circled for further work.
No formal amendment or final vote on the underlying policy was recorded on the floor; the motion to circle pauses consideration and requires the sponsor and interested members to return the bill later with revisions or additional information.
