Get Full Government Meeting Transcripts, Videos, & Alerts Forever!
Get email alerts on the Biased Incident Guidelines topic
No spam. Unsubscribe anytime.
Judiciary, attorney general debate codifying biased-incident investigation guidelines in A1921; committee releases bill
Summary
A1921, which would codify Attorney General guidelines on biased-incident investigation standards, passed the Judiciary Committee after extended questioning. The judiciary urged collaborative rulemaking; the attorney general’s office said codification would preserve standards across administrations but allowed that granular details are better left to guidelines.
The Assembly Judiciary Committee voted to release A1921, a bill to codify Attorney General guidelines governing biased-incident investigations, after a substantial exchange among committee members, the judiciary and the attorney general's office.
Pam Gellert, legislative liaison for the Administrative Offices of the Courts (Judiciary), told the committee that changes to rules of evidence typically flow through a collaborative process under the Evidence Act and cautioned that this bill, as drafted, "could allow evidence of a prior bad act to be introduced by way of hearsay" and might raise confrontation-clause issues. She recommended that significant changes be vetted through the Supreme Court’s rules committees and that time limits or context restrictions used in other jurisdictions be considered.
Steve Finkel of the Attorney General’s office said codification can preserve standards beyond one administration but acknowledged that too much granular detail in statute can constrain the office’s ability to adapt. Finkel and AG staff said they support the bill’s concept and are open to drafting adjustments that provide guardrails while addressing prosecutorial needs.
Committee members pressed for appellate-proofing language and urged consultation with the judiciary, the public defender’s appellate unit and evidence-rule experts before further action. After discussion and assurances to work on technical adjustments, the committee released A1921.
