Get Full Government Meeting Transcripts, Videos, & Alerts Forever!
Get email alerts on the HB 1170 topic
No spam. Unsubscribe anytime.
Committee narrowly votes to recommend HB 1170 for future legislation after debate over study completeness
Summary
After debate over whether the interim study was completed, the House Environment and Agriculture Committee voted to recommend HB 1170 for future legislation by a 7–6 margin following an earlier failed motion not to recommend.
The House Environment and Agriculture Committee voted to recommend HB 1170 for future legislation after a split debate over whether the committee had completed its interim study. Following an initial motion “not to recommend for future legislation,” which the chair announced had failed, Representative Bixby moved to recommend the bill and the committee approved that motion by a narrow margin.
Lawmakers split over process and substance of HB 1170, which members said requires more information before the committee should endorse forwarding it. Representative Comtois, who moved 'not to recommend for future legislation,' argued the committee had no subcommittee meeting on the topic and had “not really delved into the subject,” saying that without further work she could not vote to recommend the bill.
Other members said they had seen prior hearings and testimony and favored moving the concept forward for more work. Representative Haskins said the matter touches public health and that he would vote in favor: “it is about public health,” Haskins said, arguing it should move forward. Representative Creighton and others said the committee had agreed to study the matter and had not completed that study, and therefore initially voted against recommending it.
After the first motion failed, Representative Bixby moved to recommend HB 1170 for future legislation; the motion passed on roll call (announced in the transcript as “Motion passes 7 6”). The committee then closed its executive session on HB 1170 and moved to the next agenda items.
The record shows the committee debated both the appropriateness of deciding now and the substantive issues raised in prior testimony; members who favored recommendation framed the vote as a step to allow further work on language and amendments rather than approval of final statutory text. The committee did not adopt final statutory language; it recorded a recommendation to pursue future legislation.
The committee adjourned the HB 1170 discussion with the recommendation recorded for the committee assistant.
