Board approves Pima Elementary repurposing 3‑2 amid calls for audit and alternatives

The Scottsdale Unified School District governing board voted 3‑2 to close and repurpose Pima Elementary beginning in the 2026–27 school year, continuing a contentious agenda focused on capacity and budget pressures.

Public commenters from Pima emphasized that the school is a Title I, majority‑minority campus recently rebuilt with a roughly $18 million investment and said the district has not shared stable cost or student‑impact data. Multiple speakers called for a forensic audit, formation of a community budget committee, and exploration of marketing and growth strategies before considering closure.

Board debate mirrored the earlier Echo Canyon discussion. Supporters cited demographic trends and fiscal constraints. "SUSD is nearly 25% smaller than we were 15 years ago," Matthew Patinski said in explaining his vote; he framed the closures as part of addressing a long‑term structural deficit. Opponents responded that process and community engagement were inadequate and that alternatives were not exhausted. "The process has been flawed and I have been vocal from the beginning," Amy Carney said before casting a no vote.

The motion passed by roll call with Donna Lewis, Matthew Patinski and Mike Sharkey voting yes; Karen Warner and Amy Carney voted no. The superintendent and staff said district teams are prepared to begin individualized family outreach, boundary mapping and public hearings required by state law following the board's decision. The board directed district staff to proceed with transition supports and indicated further committee proposals will return to the board for consideration.